Establishing a system for primary realization of atmospheric ozone measurements

 

P.M. Chu and J.E. Norris

 

Objective:  To develop an advanced primary ozone standard with improved SI-traceability.  This project is in partnership with researchers at the Bureau International des Poids et Mesures (BIPM) to assure the comparability and SI-traceability of global ozone measurements.

 

Problem: The concentration of ozone in the atmosphere remains a significant issue from both scientific and political perspectives.  Ozone, at tropospheric levels, is a health concern and contributes to climate change as a greenhouse gas, while stratospheric ozone protects earth from harmful UV radiation. These concerns have led to the establishment of air quality standards and international protocols to reduce the emissions of pollutants that either contribute to tropospheric ozone formation or deplete stratospheric ozone.  Since 1983, NIST has provided Standard Reference Photometers (SRPs) based on UV photometry to ten US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) facilities to provide an infrastructure for the calibration and traceability of ozone measurements within the US.  More recently, the international interest in ozone measurements has prompted eleven national laboratories to acquire NIST SRPs.

 

Approach: To support the growing national and international need of improved ambient ozone measurements, NIST is partnering with BIPM to develop an advanced primary ozone reference standard and to share the dissemination of secondary or transfer standards. The basic project plan includes 1) Transfer the current ozone “national reference photometer” technology to BIPM.  2) Assess the performance of the current technology with respect to current and future ozone measurement requirements.  3) Provide recommendations for potential improvements of the SRPs and survey other candidate secondary standards. 4) Develop a primary reference standard with capabilities of SI-traceability verification.

 

The major challenge of this project is to incorporate a secondary method that can provide a solid foundation for the primary reference standard at relevant ozone concentrations (0 nmol/mol to 100 nmol/mol).  Additionally, any uncertainties due to ozone transport must be eliminated.  Several approaches are being considered.  Gas phase titration with nitric oxide is an attractive method, since the ozone concentration can be directly linked to primary gravimetric NO and NO2 standards. Success of this project, independent of the verification method, demands instrumentation with high sensitivity, accuracy, precision, and rapid time response for measuring chemical species at atmospheric levels (nmol/mol and lower).  In fact, minimum detection sensitivities better than 1 nmol/mol will be required to maintain uncertainties at the 1 % level for the current ground level ozone concentrations.  A number of in-situ techniques are being considered, including time-gated laser-induced fluorescence detection, tunable diode laser absorption spectroscopy, and cavity ring-down spectroscopy for detection of relevant chemical species and possible contaminants in the carrier gas.

 

 

Results and Future Plans:  Current efforts have focussed on the construction of two new NIST SRPs which are to be transferred to BIPM shortly and an initial performance evaluation of the current SRPs.  During an electronics upgrade of eleven instruments, a distinct 0.5 % slope calibration bias was noted for most of these instruments compared to SRP 2, the current principal NIST reference photometer. The calibration bias may be due to: sample memory effects in SRP 2, fluctuations in both temperature and pressure measurements for a number of instruments, variations in the zero offset dependent on the sample configuration, and significant detector drifts.  An ongoing effort is dedicated to identifying and eliminating this bias. We are also currently surveying appropriate verification methods and state-of-the-art instrumentation that can provide a solid foundation for the new primary reference standard.

As a collaborative project between NIST and BIPM, the advanced primary ozone photometer will provide an internationally validated ozone standard that can be used to anchor all ozone measurements through a defined traceability structure. The accuracy of the NIST SRP would be checked for consistency with the NIST SRM gas program and primary standards developed by BIPM.